Kit vs MailerLite for Etsy Sellers: Which Free Plan Fits a Small Shop?
Affiliate disclosure: This page has affiliate links to both Kit and MailerLite. If you pick a paid plan through one, MakerInbox may earn a commission at no extra cost to you. Because we earn from either one, this comparison isn't about which pays us more; it's about which fits your shop.
Most Etsy sellers comparing email tools land on the same two: Kit (formerly ConvertKit) and MailerLite. Both have free plans, both are beginner-friendly, and both work fine for a handmade shop.
They differ in one big way: Kit's free plan gives you a lot more subscribers. MailerLite's free plan gives you a little automation. Which one fits depends on what you'll actually do with your list.
All plan details below come from each company's pricing and help pages, checked November 9, 2026. Prices and limits change, so confirm on their sites before you choose.
The quick answer
- Pick Kit if you want room to grow for free and you're happy sending occasional manual emails ("New collection is live!"). Try Kit free
- Pick MailerLite if you want an automatic welcome email from day one, or you expect to pay a small monthly amount once you pass 250 subscribers. Try MailerLite free
If you don't know yet, start with Kit's free plan. With a 10,000-subscriber ceiling, you're unlikely to be forced to upgrade for a long time.
Free plans side by side
| Kit Free | MailerLite Free | |
|---|---|---|
| Subscriber limit | Up to 10,000 | Up to 250 |
| Monthly emails | Unlimited broadcasts | 2,500 |
| Signup forms | Unlimited | 3 active |
| Landing pages | Unlimited | 1 (plus 1 website) |
| Automations | Not included (sequences and visual automations need a paid plan) | Included, up to 3 active, 5 steps each |
| Tagging and segments | Yes | Yes |
| Sell digital products | Yes | 1 product or booking |
| What happens at the limit | Paid plan needed past 10,000 | Sending locks past 250 active subscribers until you upgrade or remove subscribers |
Sources: Kit Free plan help article, MailerLite pricing.
What this means for a small shop
Most handmade shops grow a list slowly, through package inserts, craft fairs, and social bios. Getting to 250 subscribers can take months; 10,000 is a very big list for a solo maker.
- With Kit, you'll likely stay on the free plan for a long time.
- With MailerLite, you'll hit the 250 cap sooner. When you do, sending stops until you upgrade or trim the list.
Where each one wins
Kit wins on: free room to grow
The main reason to choose Kit is the 10,000-subscriber free plan with unlimited landing pages and forms. For a shop, that means:
- A separate signup page for each product line or market booth
- A landing page for a freebie (a care guide, a printable, a pattern sample)
- Tags, so you can email only the people who care about a certain collection
The trade-off: no automations on free. When someone joins, they won't automatically get a welcome email series. You'll send broadcasts by hand when you have news, which is fine for many sellers.
Kit's paid plans: The Creator plan adds visual automations and email sequences. Kit offers a 14-day free trial of paid plans with no credit card required, and refunds paid plans within the first 30 days. Kit's Creator price depends on your list size, so check the slider on kit.com/pricing for your number.
MailerLite wins on: automation on the free plan, and a low first paid tier
MailerLite's free plan is smaller, but it includes things Kit's free plan doesn't:
- Basic automations, up to 3 active with 5 steps each. That's enough for a "Welcome + here's your freebie + meet the maker" sequence.
- A free website plus a landing page, if you want a simple home base off Etsy
- A drag-and-drop editor, a custom HTML editor, and a simple editor
The trade-off: the 250-subscriber and 2,500-emails-a-month limits. Sending 2 emails a month to 250 people is 500 sends, so the email cap is rarely the problem. The subscriber cap is the real limit.
MailerLite's paid plans: MailerLite says the Comfort plan starts at $12/month and the Power plan at $25/month, with the price rising as your list grows. Every paid plan gets the full feature set; you pay more for a bigger list or more sending. There's a 14-day premium trial with no credit card.
Which one for which kind of shop?
"I post new items a few times a year and just want to tell people." → Kit Free. Manual broadcasts are all you need, and you won't outgrow the plan.
"I want every new subscriber to get a welcome email with a code and my story." → MailerLite Free to start, since automation is included. Plan on upgrading past 250 subscribers. Or Kit Creator if you'd rather pay for Kit's tools.
"I sell digital downloads (patterns, printables, SVGs) as well as physical items." → Both let you sell digital products. Kit's free plan includes digital products and subscriptions. MailerLite's free plan allows 1 product or booking. If digital products are a big part of your business, look at Kit first.
"I'm also building my own Shopify store." → Check the integrations list for each tool before choosing. MailerLite lists Shopify and WooCommerce integrations on its pricing page. Either tool can work, but test the connection during the free trial.
Things that matter less than you'd think
- Templates. Both have them. Plain, short emails often do well for small shops anyway.
- Advanced analytics. At under 1,000 subscribers, open and click counts are all you need.
- "Best deliverability" claims. Both are established platforms. What you do matters more: mail only people who opted in, and keep a steady schedule.
Things that matter more than you'd think
- Consent. Whichever tool you choose, don't import Etsy order emails. Etsy's Seller Policy prohibits adding buyers to your mailing list without their consent. See Can You Email Your Etsy Customers?
- Your mailing address. US marketing emails need a valid physical postal address under CAN-SPAM. Both tools ask for one. A registered PO Box works if you don't want to show your home address.
- Moving later. Switching tools isn't a disaster. Kit offers free migration on paid plans. Still, picking the right free plan now saves effort.
Our recommendation
For most Etsy and handmade sellers just starting a list: start with Kit's free plan. The 10,000-subscriber ceiling and unlimited landing pages make it hard to outgrow, and manual "new drop" emails are what most small shops send anyway.
Choose MailerLite instead if an automated welcome email matters to you from day one and you're fine with a small monthly bill once you pass 250 subscribers.
Next step: How to Add a QR Code Email Signup to Your Etsy Package Inserts, which walks through the easiest way to get your first 50 subscribers.
FAQ
Is Kit the same as ConvertKit? Yes. ConvertKit rebranded as Kit.
Can I use both? You can, but it's not worth it. Pick one so all your subscribers are in one place.
Does either one connect directly to Etsy? Don't assume so. We didn't see a direct Etsy connection on either company's pricing page, so check their integrations directory if it matters to you. You shouldn't sync buyer emails into a marketing list anyway. Collect subscribers through a signup form instead.
Which is cheaper once I pay? It depends on your list size and billing period. MailerLite's paid plans start lower ($12/month for Comfort, per MailerLite). Kit's free plan lasts much longer before you need to pay. Compare both pricing pages at your actual subscriber count.
Sources checked Nov 9, 2026: Kit pricing, Kit Free plan, MailerLite pricing and FAQ, Etsy Seller Policy, 16 CFR Part 316.
Get one useful email a month
Short, practical tips for growing a list and a simple website for your handmade shop. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.
By subscribing you agree to our privacy policy.